Saturday, January 23, 2010

Week 2: Cultures within the Public Sphere

From a Postmodern standpoint, I can see why cultures within the PS are necessary. What I don't understand, as I pointed out in class, is why some of these cultures seem to be defined by stereotypes. Dr. Rowan made a good point, "we have to make some generalizations in defining these cultures". One generalization that really bothered me was McKee using the term "queer culture" when referring to the gay community. According to McKee, "Queer Nation...takes the insult 'queer' and turns it into a proud celebration of diversity"(30). As I stated in class, I have many gay friends that would actually be very offended by the term "queer". McKee justifies using this term by stating that,"from a postmodern perspective it is in fact a positive thing"(30). Having postmodern views, I do think that this term will one day be used openly when describing the gay community, but I don't hink that day is today.
Another thing that really caught my eye about cultures within the PS was McKee's generalization of the white culture. The white culture is "composed of literate and restrained forms of public communication"(25), immediately made me think of George W. Bush. If you click on the following link http://politicalhumor.about.com/library/bl_bush_quote_generator.htmtor.htm there are several Bush quotes that would make this generalization seem like a stereotype. I'm not saying Bush is illiterate, but he was known for making up words in public speeches.
I think many of my opinions about issues would make me a postmodernist. Cultures within the PS are necessary because each culture has different issues that need to be addressed. Making generalizations about these cultures, whether or not they are stereotypes, is necessary in defining a culture.

1 comment:

  1. "The white culture is "composed of literate and restrained forms of public communication." I think you do a good job with the G. Bush example of highlighting the fallacy in this thinking. This quote raises another question for me--might not some other cultures/classes be thought traditionally "literate and restrained" if they had the benefit of the extra two hundred years of the thoughtful exchange that white men have had access to in the PS?

    ReplyDelete